|
What’s
in the New Federal Prescription Drug Plan?
The bill passed in by
congress in December to provide
prescription drug coverage to Medicare recipients is highly
controversial. Those on the political
right object to its
cost, and those on the political left object to its favoritism for
health
insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies as well as its
potential harm
to existing coverage. It is possible
that the bill will be modified before taking full effect, but we
present below
some major provisions in the current bill.
Most of the facts were provided by Bill Pharo, based on
information in
an AARP summary. Your newsletter editor
has done minor editing and has added some information from other
sources
including recent Letters to the Editor of the newspaper The
Record by the
two senators from
New Jersey.
Items 1 through 3 below
apply to a family that has no
current prescription drug coverage but does have Medicare Parts A &
B:
1. The bill provides some
help
via the interim discount card for those that spend over $300 on
prescription
drugs for most of year 2004 and all of year 2005. The low income
provision is
of no value to New Jersey Seniors, because PAAD is a better alternative. (Even those with higher incomes might not
benefit, because other discount cards are already available, for
instance the
one offered free by Chilton Memorial Hospital).
2. In the year 2006,
individuals
in the family have the option to either (a) make no change in their
Medicare
plan, or (b) to select the Medicare drug plan at $35 per month ($420
per year),
or (c) to seek a private health plan that offers a stand-alone drug
plan or a
combined health and drug plan. (Incidentally many seniors have already
left
Medicare Part B for private health plans that have drug coverage. The
new bill
offers them the choice to return to Medicare Part B with drug coverage
if that
is a better deal.)
3. The Medicare drug plan
will
provide some savings to those who spend over $670 a year for
prescription
medicines: It will pay 75% of drug costs
over $250, up to $2250 per year. Thus a
person can save as much as $1500 per year (75 % of $2000) minus the
$420 annual
insurance cost). However, for the next
$3850 in costs there is a hole in coverage, and the plan will pay
nothing Then, starting at $5100 in costs,
the plan
will pay 95%.
One open
question concerns individuals covered by their employer’s Drug
plan: If the employer forces them into the Medicare Drug plan, some
individuals
may get poorer coverage. The Bill provides a significant subsidy to
employers
to avoid this migration, but the companies are under no obligation to
retain
their plans.
There are other
concerns: The bill permits private health
insurance
companies to compete with Medicare, and the private companies are
allowed to
“cherry pick”, that is, to accept only the healthiest applicants, thus
achieving windfall profits while burdening Medicare (and thus the
taxpayers)
with those who will impose the heaviest financial burdens.
Perhaps worst of all, the
bill prohibits the government from
negotiating price
with the pharmaceutical companies. It
must accept whatever price the companies set.
Because of the concerns
and objections noted above, as
well as other controversial areas, there is a movement to amend the
bill. Therefore some details given in this
article
may have changed by the time the bill goes into full effect. However, even in its present form, the plan
will provide some coverage for those who currently have none.
|